Who Should Help You Plan Roth Conversions: Your CPA or Financial Advisor?
You’re retired with a large traditional IRA.
You know Roth conversions may make sense.
Your CPA prepares your tax return.
Your financial advisor manages your investments and retirement plan.
So who should actually decide:
How much should you convert to Roth this year?
Our answer is usually:
Neither one should be making that decision in isolation.
A Roth conversion sits directly between tax planning and financial planning.
Your CPA may understand the tax return better than anyone.
Your financial planner should understand your retirement plan, portfolio, future RMDs, Social Security, Medicare, spending and long-term goals.
The best Roth conversion strategy often happens when those two perspectives come together.
Tax Preparation and Tax Planning Are Different Jobs
This is an important distinction.
Many CPAs are primarily hired to:
prepare tax returns
calculate tax liability
make sure reporting is correct
handle filings
answer technical tax questions
Those are incredibly important responsibilities.
But Roth conversion planning asks a different set of questions.
Not simply:
What happened last year?
But:
What should we intentionally make happen before December 31?
And then:
How does that decision affect the next five, ten or twenty years?
Some CPAs absolutely provide proactive, multi-year tax planning.
Others are primarily focused on compliance and preparation.
Neither approach is inherently wrong.
The important thing is knowing which service you are actually receiving — and making sure someone is responsible for connecting the tax return to the long-term financial plan.
A Roth Conversion Is Not Just a Tax Transaction
Imagine a retiree with:
a large traditional IRA
a taxable brokerage account
Social Security
significant long-term capital gains
Medicare
several years before required minimum distributions
charitable goals
children who may eventually inherit retirement accounts
The narrow tax question might be:
How much can we convert while staying in the 24% bracket?
But that is only the beginning.
We also want to know:
What do we expect future RMDs to look like?
What happens if one spouse dies and the survivor eventually files single?
What tax rate might heirs pay on inherited IRA distributions?
Will the conversion increase Medicare IRMAA?
Should we realize capital gains this year or next year?
Should Social Security begin now or later?
Are there charitable strategies that reduce future IRA balances?
Where will the cash come from to pay the tax?
Does paying the tax today interfere with another financial goal?
A tax projection can calculate the tax on a conversion.
It cannot, by itself, determine whether the conversion improves the financial plan.
This Is Where Roth Conversion Planning Gets Tricky
One of the easiest mistakes is looking at a tax projection and assuming one headline income number tells you everything.
Imagine someone has more than $400,000 of taxable income.
At first glance, it may look like there is very little room remaining in the 24% ordinary-income bracket.
But what if a large portion of that taxable income comes from long-term capital gains?
Now the composition of the income matters.
Long-term capital gains still count as income and can affect numerous tax calculations, but they are generally taxed under a separate preferential rate structure rather than simply being treated as ordinary income.
That means a household with substantial capital gains may have more room for ordinary income from a Roth conversion than the headline income number suggests.
We go much deeper into that distinction in Why Your AGI Doesn't Tell You How Much Room You Have for a Roth Conversion.
This is one reason Roth conversion planning can become difficult even for people who understand taxes well.
You have to know what is actually inside the return.
Think of the Tax Return Like a Layered Cake
One way we explain this is as a layered cake.
The first layer might contain ordinary income such as:
pension income
IRA withdrawals
Roth conversions
interest
short-term capital gains
taxable Social Security
Then another layer may contain:
qualified dividends
long-term capital gains
Those layers interact.
But they are not all taxed the same way.
That is why simply saying:
“Your taxable income is $400,000.”
does not answer:
“How much room do we have for another Roth conversion at 24%?”
You have to understand how the layers fit together.
This is exactly the type of issue where a financial planner and CPA can be more effective working together than separately.
A Real Planning Situation Can Change Quickly
Consider an anonymized example based on a type of planning conversation we have had.
A retired couple had:
large long-term capital gains
IRA distributions
Social Security
dividends
deductions that varied from year to year
an ongoing multi-year Roth conversion strategy
At first glance, the projection suggested there was very little room for another Roth conversion without pushing ordinary income into a higher bracket.
But as the financial planner and CPA worked through the calculation together, an important distinction emerged.
A large portion of taxable income consisted of long-term capital gains.
Once those gains were separated from the ordinary-income calculation, the amount of available Roth conversion room changed materially.
The lesson was not:
The CPA made a mistake.
The lesson was:
This is complicated enough that collaboration matters.
The CPA understood the tax return.
The financial planning team understood:
where the investment income came from
what gains had already been realized
how much IRA money remained
what had been converted in prior years
which income sources could still be controlled
what future income was expected
why the Roth conversions were being done in the first place
Put those pieces together and the strategy became clearer.
Your CPA May Be Looking at a Different Problem
A CPA may be focused on questions such as:
What is the projected tax liability?
What deductions are available?
Are estimated payments sufficient?
What carryforwards apply?
Is the tax return being reported correctly?
What happens if we add another $50,000 of income?
Those are exactly the questions we want a CPA thinking about.
The financial planner may be focused on a different set:
How much IRA money remains?
How many years do we have before RMDs?
What are future pension or deferred-compensation payments?
How much portfolio income can we control?
Are we planning to realize gains anyway?
What will the surviving spouse’s tax situation look like?
How much of the IRA may eventually pass to children?
What does the client actually want the money to accomplish?
A Roth conversion sits directly between those two sets of questions.
The Financial Planner Should Be Thinking Several Tax Years Ahead
Suppose we are planning for 2026.
The narrow question is:
How much should we convert in 2026?
But perhaps the bigger question is:
How should we distribute $600,000 or $800,000 of potential conversions across the next four years?
Maybe this year is unusually attractive.
Maybe next year includes a large deferred-compensation payment.
Maybe Social Security begins in two years.
Maybe required minimum distributions begin several years after that.
Maybe one year will be particularly good for itemized deductions.
Maybe a business or property sale is coming.
Those future events matter because the goal isn't necessarily to find the lowest possible tax bill this year.
The goal is to determine when it is most advantageous to recognize taxable income over the entire planning horizon.
Sometimes Good Tax Planning Means Paying More Tax Today
That can sound backwards.
Most people assume:
Better tax planning = lower taxes this year.
Not always.
Suppose you can intentionally convert $100,000 from a traditional IRA at a 24% marginal rate today.
If you don't convert it, the money remains inside the IRA.
Years later, perhaps:
required minimum distributions begin
one spouse dies
the surviving spouse moves into narrower single-filer brackets
or the children inherit the IRA while they are in high-earning years
The same dollars might eventually be taxed at a higher rate.
In that situation, deliberately creating a larger tax bill today may improve the long-term result.
That is why we repeatedly come back to one principle:
The tax answer should not live in a vacuum.
The lowest tax bill this April is not necessarily the best tax plan.
Sometimes the Better Decision Is to Convert Less
The opposite is also true.
Suppose another $75,000 conversion:
pushes ordinary income into a significantly higher bracket
creates a meaningful Medicare IRMAA increase
interferes with another valuable deduction or credit
creates more tax than the long-term benefit justifies
requires using cash the client needs for another purpose
Then slowing down may make sense.
Roth conversion planning should not become:
Convert as much as possible.
It should be:
How much should we intentionally convert this year given everything else we know?
Sometimes that is $50,000.
Sometimes it is $150,000.
Sometimes it is zero.
Medicare IRMAA Is a Cost — Not Necessarily a Stop Sign
Medicare creates another common tension.
A Roth conversion can increase Modified Adjusted Gross Income and potentially push a retiree into a higher IRMAA tier.
The natural reaction is:
Don't cross the IRMAA threshold.
Maybe.
But we want to know what crossing it actually costs.
Suppose moving into the next tier increases Medicare premiums by several thousand dollars.
If that allows a much larger Roth conversion at a tax rate we believe is attractive, paying the additional Medicare premium may still be worthwhile.
On the other hand, if someone is only slightly above a threshold and we can reduce income without sacrificing another important goal, avoiding the higher premium may make sense.
The answer is not:
Always avoid IRMAA.
And it is not:
Ignore IRMAA.
The answer is:
Price the tradeoff.
We discuss that more in Retiring After a High-Income Career: How to Reduce IRMAA When Medicare Is Upcoming.
Capital Gains Should Be Coordinated With Roth Conversions
Suppose the retiree also owns appreciated investments in a taxable brokerage account.
Those investments may need to be sold eventually.
The question becomes:
Which year should recognize those gains?
Perhaps next year will have a particularly sensitive income threshold.
Maybe next year is when we want to maximize itemized deductions.
Maybe a deferred-compensation payment will arrive.
Maybe we want to preserve more Roth conversion room.
It can sometimes make sense to intentionally realize more long-term gains in the current year if doing so creates more planning flexibility later.
Again, the goal isn't:
Minimize this year's tax bill at all costs.
Sometimes a “messier” tax year today creates a cleaner planning year tomorrow.
Your financial planner may know well in advance that portfolio gains are likely to be realized.
That information belongs in the tax conversation before the trades happen.
Deductions Can Be Planned Across Years Too
The same concept can apply to deductions.
Suppose a retired couple is close to taking the standard deduction this year.
They may have some flexibility around:
charitable gifts
certain tax payments
other deductible expenses
Instead of spreading those deductions evenly across years, perhaps they intentionally bunch more of them into one year.
Now the plan might look something like:
Year 1: Larger Roth conversion while taking the standard deduction.
Year 2: Smaller Roth conversion while maximizing itemized deductions.
That doesn't mean everyone should do this.
It demonstrates the larger point:
Roth conversion planning is not just about the Roth conversion.
It is about coordinating the conversion with the rest of the tax picture.
Your CPA Shouldn't First Learn About the Strategy at Tax Time
Imagine meeting with your CPA in March and saying:
By the way, we converted $250,000 to Roth in November.
At that point, the CPA can calculate the consequences.
But the decision has already been made.
Maybe the better amount was $175,000.
Maybe it was $300,000.
Maybe a capital gain should have been recognized in the same year.
Maybe a charitable strategy should have happened first.
Many of those decisions become much harder — or impossible — after December 31.
That is why we generally like proactive coordination before year-end.
Why Late-Year Planning Can Be So Valuable
We like thinking about Roth conversions throughout the year.
But there is often value in sharpening the final amount later in the year.
By October or November, we may have a much clearer picture of:
realized capital gains
dividends
pension income
consulting income
charitable giving
property taxes
portfolio distributions
Social Security
other unexpected income
Then the financial planner and CPA can update the projection before making the final conversion.
This also gives us a natural annual rhythm.
Review the previous tax return.
Update the current-year income picture.
Estimate the final conversion.
Execute before year-end.
Then repeat next year.
That process is one reason we believe retirees should review their tax return every year.
The return tells us what happened.
Planning tells us what to do next.
What Should the Financial Planner Bring to the CPA?
A productive tax-planning meeting becomes much more useful when the planner brings clean information.
That might include:
Roth conversions already completed
IRA distributions
realized capital gains and losses
estimated remaining portfolio gains
dividend income
Social Security
pension income
deferred compensation
planned charitable gifts
major upcoming financial transactions
The CPA shouldn't have to guess what is happening inside the investment portfolio.
And the financial planner shouldn't have to guess what the tax return looks like.
What Should the CPA Bring to the Financial Planner?
The planner also needs the CPA's expertise.
We want to understand:
projected taxable income
marginal tax rates
capital-gain treatment
deductions
carryforwards
estimated tax payments
unusual tax items
potential tax cliffs
technical limitations
whether the planning assumptions actually reconcile with the tax return
The goal is not for one professional to replace the other.
It is for the two sets of expertise to connect.
What If Your CPA Already Does Multi-Year Planning?
That's great.
There are CPAs who do excellent proactive planning.
Some already model:
Roth conversions
capital gains
Medicare
charitable giving
future income
RMDs
If your CPA is doing that, you have a valuable planning resource.
The goal of this article is not to argue that every financial advisor knows more about Roth conversions than every CPA.
That would be silly.
The point is that preparing a tax return and owning a long-term financial strategy are different responsibilities.
Someone needs to be responsible for connecting them.
What If Your Financial Advisor Never Wants to See Your Tax Return?
That would concern us more.
If an advisor recommends:
Roth conversions
charitable distributions
large portfolio sales
IRA withdrawals
retirement-income strategies
but never wants to understand the tax return or coordinate with the CPA, something is missing.
Investment decisions create tax consequences.
Tax decisions create investment consequences.
You can make individually reasonable recommendations that work poorly together if nobody is looking at the whole picture.
Who Should Actually Decide the Roth Conversion Amount?
Ultimately, the client does.
But a good process might look something like this:
Financial planner:
Here's why we think Roth conversions fit the long-term plan.
CPA:
Here's how the proposed conversion affects this year's tax return.
Financial planner:
Here's how different conversion amounts affect future RMDs, portfolio withdrawals, cash flow, Medicare and legacy planning.
CPA:
Here's the tax impact of those scenarios.
Client:
Here's how much tax we're comfortable intentionally paying today.
Then everyone agrees on the amount.
That is much more powerful than asking one professional:
What's the biggest Roth conversion I can do?
The Real Question Is Who Owns the Long-Term Plan
This is the part we think matters most.
Someone needs to understand:
Why are we doing the Roth conversion in the first place?
Maybe the goal is to reduce future RMDs.
Maybe it is to protect a surviving spouse from future higher tax rates.
Maybe it is to create more tax-free assets for heirs.
Maybe it is to take advantage of several low-income years immediately after retirement.
Maybe it is to create more flexibility over where future retirement income comes from.
Usually it is some combination.
If nobody owns that long-term objective, Roth conversion planning can easily become:
We're in the 24% bracket, so let's convert.
That's incomplete.
The tax calculation should support the financial plan.
The financial plan should determine what we're trying to accomplish.
The Bottom Line
So who should help you plan a Roth conversion?
Your CPA or your financial advisor?
Ideally, both.
Your CPA can help answer:
What are the tax consequences if we do this?
Your financial planner should help answer:
Why are we doing it, how much should we do, and how does it affect the rest of the financial plan?
Then those professionals should coordinate before the transaction happens.
Because the best Roth conversion isn't necessarily the conversion that creates the lowest tax bill this year.
It's the conversion that improves your long-term after-tax financial outcome.
And figuring that out usually requires looking beyond a single tax return.
Related Resources
Why Your AGI Doesn't Tell You How Much Room You Have for a Roth Conversion
Roth Conversions for Legacy Planning: Should You Pay the Tax Before Your Children Inherit?
Retiring After a High-Income Career: How to Reduce IRMAA When Medicare Is Upcoming
This material is for educational purposes only and is not intended as individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Tax laws and individual circumstances vary. Financial planning decisions should be coordinated with appropriate tax and financial professionals.