Broker Check
Why Retirees Should Review Their Tax Return Every Year

Why Retirees Should Review Their Tax Return Every Year

February 05, 2026

Why Retirees Should Review Their Tax Return Every Year

Most people think of a tax return as something that gets prepared, filed, and then put away.

For retirees, we think it can be much more useful than that.

A tax return is one of the best places to look for clues about whether the rest of the financial plan is working the way we expect.

Sometimes the return reveals something that looks wrong.

Sometimes it reveals something that is technically correct but financially inefficient.

And sometimes it confirms that a planning strategy we intentionally implemented is showing up the way we expected.

Those are three very different things.

And all three are reasons we review tax returns as part of the financial planning process.

Sometimes Something Simply Doesn't Look Right

Recently, we reviewed a retired client's tax return after she told us something that immediately got our attention:

She unexpectedly had to write a check to the IRS.

That doesn't automatically mean anything was wrong.

But when someone has a surprise tax bill, we want to understand why.

As we reviewed the return, one number stood out.

There was $15,000 of pension income reported.

It was a perfectly round number, which is unusual.

More importantly, that income had not appeared on her prior-year returns.

She didn't know where it came from.

And there was no reason she should have known.

She is in her 80s.

She isn't reviewing every tax form line by line.

She is relying on the professionals around her to help make sure the pieces fit together.

At this point, we don't know whether the number was an error, a reporting change, or something else entirely.

So the next step was simple:

Have the CPA confirm it.

That is an important distinction.

We are not assuming the tax preparer made a mistake.

We are simply saying:

“This doesn't match what we know about the client's financial life, so let's investigate it.”

Sometimes financial planning is sophisticated.

Sometimes it's noticing one number and asking:

“Where did that come from?”

Sometimes the Tax Return Is Correct — but the Strategy Behind It Isn't Ideal

Another retiree we began working with had a very different issue.

There wasn't necessarily anything wrong with her tax return.

The problem was what the return was telling us about her investment portfolio.

Her funds were generating six figures of capital gains.

Those gains increased her taxable income enough to help push her into the highest IRMAA bracket, meaning she was also paying significantly higher Medicare premiums.

The return may have been reporting exactly what happened.

But what happened wasn't necessarily efficient.

That is a different type of problem.

The first client prompted the question:

“Is this income supposed to be here?”

The second prompted:

“Why are we creating this much taxable income in the first place?”

Once we understood what was driving the gains, the planning opportunity was much clearer.

The investment strategy could be made more tax-aware.

That doesn't mean eliminating capital gains.

Good investing sometimes creates taxable gains.

But there is a meaningful difference between paying taxes because wealth grew and paying unnecessary taxes because the investments are routinely distributing income or gains in an inefficient way.

For retirees, the consequences can extend beyond the income-tax return.

Taxable income can also affect:

  • how much of Social Security is taxable,

  • Medicare Part B premiums,

  • Medicare Part D premiums,

  • capital-gains taxation,

  • and how much flexibility exists for Roth conversions or other tax strategies.

That is why investment management and tax planning shouldn't live in separate silos.

The Tax Return Can Also Confirm That Planning Strategies Are Working

The return isn't only useful when we're looking for problems.

It can also tell us whether the planning we intentionally put in place is flowing through correctly.

With the same retired client whose unexplained pension income caught our attention, we also help coordinate Qualified Charitable Distributions, or QCDs, from her IRA.

She already wants to give to charity.

The planning question is:

What is the most tax-efficient way to make those gifts?

Once someone is eligible, a QCD can allow money to move directly from an IRA to a qualifying charity.

When the rules are satisfied, that distribution can count toward the person's Required Minimum Distribution while generally staying out of taxable income.

That can be very different from:

  1. taking an IRA distribution personally,

  2. reporting the income,

  3. and then writing a check to charity.

The charitable intent is the same.

The tax result may not be.

So when we review that client's tax return, we're not only checking for something unusual.

We're also asking:

Did the QCD strategy show up the way we expected?

That is another important role of tax-return review.

We want the plan and the tax return to tell the same story.

A Tax Return Is More Than a Filing Document

A CPA's job is to prepare and file the tax return based on the information available to them.

A financial advisor should be looking at that same return from a different angle.

We want to understand:

  • Where did the income come from?

  • Did anything change from last year?

  • Are distributions showing up where we expect?

  • Did a Roth conversion get reported as planned?

  • Are charitable strategies showing up the way we intended?

  • Did capital gains spike?

  • Is the portfolio producing unnecessary taxable income?

  • Is Social Security being taxed differently?

  • Did withholding keep up with the actual tax liability?

  • Could income be affecting Medicare premiums?

That is a different type of review.

We are not preparing the return.

We are looking for whether the return makes sense in the context of the financial plan.

Unexpected Tax Bills Are a Signal

One of the simplest triggers for a tax review is an unexpected bill.

If a retiree tells us:

“I had to write a much bigger check to the IRS than I expected,”

we want to know why.

Sometimes the explanation is straightforward.

Maybe:

  • withholding was too low,

  • a larger IRA distribution occurred,

  • capital gains were realized,

  • interest income increased,

  • a Roth conversion was completed,

  • or estimated tax payments were not adjusted.

Other times, something on the return may not match what we expected.

The point is not to assume a mistake.

The point is to investigate the reason.

What We Look for on a Retiree's Tax Return

Retirement tax planning gets more complicated because income can come from many different places.

A retiree may have:

  • Social Security

  • pension income

  • IRA withdrawals

  • Required Minimum Distributions

  • Roth conversions

  • dividends

  • interest

  • capital gains

  • rental income

  • annuity income

  • charitable distributions

Each one can affect the tax return differently.

That creates a lot of opportunities for something to change from one year to the next.

Pension Income That Looks Different

Pensions are often fairly predictable.

So if pension income suddenly appears, disappears, or changes significantly, we want to understand why.

A perfectly round number can also be worth asking about.

That doesn't mean a round number is wrong.

But when something appears unexpectedly and doesn't match prior years, it's worth confirming.

The important word is confirming.

Not accusing.

Not assuming.

Just making sure we understand what we're looking at.

IRA Distributions and RMDs

For retirees taking distributions from traditional IRAs, we want to make sure the reported income makes sense relative to what actually came out of the account.

That becomes increasingly important once Required Minimum Distributions begin.

Questions we might ask include:

  • Was the full RMD taken?

  • Was it taken from the correct account?

  • Was withholding sufficient?

  • Was a QCD completed?

  • Does the taxable amount appear consistent with that strategy?

A small reporting or planning difference can create a very different tax result.

Roth Conversions

Roth conversions are another area we review closely.

If someone intentionally converted a portion of a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, we expect to see that reflected on the return.

But the question isn't simply:

“Did the conversion appear?”

It's:

“Did the conversion appear the way we expected?”

And then:

“Did the amount still make sense once we see the rest of the year's income?”

That is especially important when Medicare premiums, capital gains, or other income thresholds are part of the plan.

Capital Gains

Capital gains deserve more attention than people sometimes realize.

A retiree may have a large gain because:

  • investments were sold,

  • a mutual fund distributed capital gains,

  • a portfolio was rebalanced,

  • property was sold,

  • or an investment strategy itself is generating significant taxable distributions.

A large capital gain isn't automatically bad.

But it should have a reason.

If a portfolio is routinely creating substantial taxable gains without a planning benefit, we want to understand whether there is a more tax-aware way to invest.

This is where investment management becomes tax planning.

IRMAA Can Turn Investment Inefficiency Into a Medicare Problem

For higher-income retirees, taxes aren't the only consequence.

Medicare uses income to determine whether someone pays additional Part B and Part D premiums through IRMAA.

That means a tax-inefficient investment strategy can potentially increase two costs at once:

Taxes.

And Medicare premiums.

That was exactly what made the investment example so important.

The issue wasn't simply:

“This fund had a big capital-gains distribution.”

It was:

“This portfolio is creating enough taxable income that it is affecting another part of the retirement plan.”

That's why we like reviewing everything together.

Social Security Taxation

Social Security can also be confusing because the amount someone receives is not always the same as the amount included in taxable income.

A retiree may see their tax bill rise and assume Social Security changed.

Sometimes the real issue is that other income increased enough to make more of the Social Security benefit taxable.

Again, one income source can affect another.

That is why we don't review one line in isolation.

Charitable Giving and QCDs

For charitably inclined retirees, QCDs can be a particularly useful strategy.

If someone is already giving to charity, the question becomes whether the charitable gift can also improve the tax picture.

When eligible, a QCD can:

  • send money directly from an IRA to a qualifying charity,

  • count toward an RMD,

  • and generally keep that qualifying distribution out of taxable income.

That can matter for more than just the federal income-tax bill.

Lower adjusted gross income may also help with other parts of the retirement plan.

So when we know a client completed QCDs during the year, that is something we specifically want to see reflected appropriately when the return is prepared.

Withholding Can Matter More Than the Final Tax Rate

Sometimes the tax plan itself is fine.

The surprise is simply the timing.

A retiree may owe roughly the amount of tax we expected but still be surprised at filing time because not enough was withheld during the year.

That can happen when:

  • pension withholding is too low,

  • IRA distributions have insufficient withholding,

  • Social Security withholding wasn't elected,

  • investment income increased,

  • or a large one-time transaction occurred.

In that situation, the solution may be straightforward.

Adjust withholding or estimated payments.

The goal isn't necessarily to reduce the tax.

It's to eliminate the surprise.

The Tax Return Can Reveal Opportunity

We aren't only searching for things that went wrong.

Sometimes the return tells us the client has more planning room than expected.

Maybe taxable income is lower.

That could create an opportunity for:

  • Roth conversions,

  • realizing capital gains intentionally,

  • changing the investment strategy,

  • or accelerating income.

Maybe the return shows unusually high interest income because too much money is sitting in cash.

Maybe charitable giving can be structured differently.

Maybe an investment strategy is creating unnecessary taxable distributions.

The return tells us what happened.

Financial planning asks:

“What should we do differently because of it?”

Why This Matters More as You Get Older

As people move deeper into retirement, the financial system can become more complicated.

Pensions begin.

Social Security starts.

RMDs arrive.

Medicare premiums depend on income.

Investment accounts continue producing dividends and gains.

Charitable giving strategies change.

Tax laws change.

And eventually, the person managing all of this may simply not want to spend their time studying tax forms.

That is completely reasonable.

An 80-year-old retiree should not need to know whether a $15,000 pension entry looks unusual.

But someone on their financial team should be paying attention.

Your CPA and Financial Advisor Should Complement Each Other

We don't see the CPA and financial advisor relationship as competitive.

They are often looking at the same financial life from different angles.

The CPA is primarily asking:

“How do we accurately report what happened?”

The financial advisor should also be asking:

“Does what happened make sense relative to the plan?”

And sometimes:

“Should we change the plan so this doesn't happen again?”

Those perspectives are more valuable together.

A Practical Tax Return Review Checklist for Retirees

Each year, we generally want to compare the current return to the prior year and ask:

  1. Did total income change materially?

  2. Did any new pension or annuity income appear?

  3. Were IRA distributions what we expected?

  4. Were RMDs handled correctly?

  5. Did QCDs appear consistent with the strategy?

  6. Did Roth conversions show up as planned?

  7. Did capital gains increase unexpectedly?

  8. Is the portfolio generating more taxable income than necessary?

  9. Did interest or dividend income change significantly?

  10. Did Social Security taxation change?

  11. Was withholding sufficient?

  12. Did anything increase Medicare or IRMAA exposure?

  13. Is there anything on the return that simply doesn't make sense?

That last question may be the most important.

Sometimes tax planning is noticing a number and asking:

“Where did that come from?”

Other times it is noticing a number and asking:

“Why are we creating this income in the first place?”

The Bottom Line

A tax return should not be something a retiree signs and forgets.

It is one of the most useful financial documents we receive each year.

It can show whether:

  • something looks wrong,

  • the investment strategy is creating unnecessary taxable income,

  • Medicare premiums are being affected,

  • charitable strategies are working,

  • Roth conversions were implemented correctly,

  • withholding needs to change,

  • or new planning opportunities have opened up.

Recently, one tax return caused us to question an unexpected $15,000 pension entry.

We don't yet know whether anything was wrong.

Another retiree's return showed us that her investment portfolio was generating six figures of capital gains and contributing to much higher Medicare premiums.

And with the first client, we also use the return to confirm that the QCD strategy we help implement is showing up the way we expect.

Those are three completely different situations.

But they all come back to the same idea:

A tax return is not just a compliance document. It is a financial-planning document.

At Apeiron Planning Partners, we think part of having a financial partner is having someone who knows enough about your financial life to recognize when the numbers don't make sense—or when they make perfect sense but the strategy behind them could be better.

Learn more about tax planning

Learn more about retirement planning

What To Do With Excess RMDs

Understanding Medicare and IRMAA: What Retirees Need to Know

Schedule a conversation

Related Resources

This material is for general informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as individualized financial, tax, accounting, or legal advice. Tax laws, reporting requirements, and individual circumstances vary. Readers should consult their CPA, tax professional, financial advisor, or other appropriate professionals regarding their specific situation.