Roth Conversions for Legacy Planning: Should You Pay the Tax Before Your Children Inherit?
At some point, retirement planning can change.
Early on, the questions are usually:
Are we saving enough?
Can we retire comfortably?
Will our money last?
But once those questions are largely answered, a different one starts to matter:
What happens to the money we don't spend?
For many families, that leads to a deeper tax-planning question:
Should we intentionally pay more tax during our lifetime so our children inherit less taxable money later?
That's where Roth conversions can become part of legacy planning.
Legacy Planning Isn't Just About Wills and Trusts
When people hear “legacy planning,” they usually think about estate documents.
Wills.
Trusts.
Beneficiary designations.
Those are important.
But there's another layer:
What type of assets are your children actually going to inherit?
A child inheriting:
- Cash
- A taxable brokerage account
- A traditional IRA
- A Roth IRA
can have very different tax consequences.
That's why legacy planning and tax planning increasingly overlap.
The Problem With Leaving Large Pre-Tax Accounts
Traditional 401(k)s and IRAs are powerful wealth-building tools.
You generally received a tax benefit when the money went in.
But the tax hasn't disappeared.
It's been deferred.
Eventually, somebody usually pays it.
That may be:
you, during retirement
your surviving spouse
or
your children after they inherit the account
That's the core tradeoff.
The question isn't simply:
“How do I minimize my taxes?”
It may become:
“How do we minimize taxes across our lifetime and our children's?”
That's a much bigger planning question.
Inherited IRAs Can Create a Compressed Tax Window
For many non-spouse beneficiaries, inherited retirement accounts generally must be fully distributed within 10 years after the original owner's death.
That matters.
Imagine your children are already in their peak earning years when they inherit a large traditional IRA.
Now they may be adding required or planned IRA distributions on top of:
- Salary
- Bonuses
- Business income
- Investment income
- Their own retirement distributions later
The inheritance is obviously still valuable.
But the tax timing may be much less attractive than the parents originally experienced while accumulating the account.
This is exactly the kind of issue that started surfacing in recent client conversations: not simply “What will our children inherit?”, but “What tax problem are we potentially handing them with it?”
Does That Mean You Should Convert Everything to Roth?
No.
This is where the planning gets more nuanced.
A Roth conversion means voluntarily moving money from a pre-tax retirement account into Roth and generally recognizing taxable income today.
In exchange, you're changing the tax character of the money going forward.
The temptation is to say:
“If Roth is better for the kids, let's convert everything.”
But that's not how we'd approach it.
Your retirement still comes first.
The right strategy needs to balance:
- Your current tax bracket
- Your expected future tax bracket
- Future RMDs
- Cash available to pay conversion taxes
- Medicare and IRMAA
- The surviving spouse's future tax picture
- Your children's likely tax situation
- How much money you actually expect to leave behind
Legacy planning shouldn't create a worse retirement for the people who earned the money.
Sometimes the Goal Changes Once You Know You're Okay
This was one of the most interesting themes from the conversations we reviewed.
Earlier in retirement planning, the priority is often:
Don't run out of money.
Later, once the plan becomes stronger and the probability of leaving substantial assets rises, the question can shift to:
What should we do differently for the next generation?
That may justify a different Roth-conversion strategy than you would have used 10 or 15 years earlier.
One family we spoke with framed it almost exactly that way: once their own retirement was sufficiently funded, they wanted the planning conversation to look beyond their lives and consider how the assets would eventually reach their children.
Another long-retired couple arrived at the same question from the other side: if their son was likely to inherit meaningful IRA assets, should they be thinking about taxes across two generations, rather than only minimizing taxes during their own lifetime?
That's where legacy planning becomes more interesting.
Your Children's Tax Brackets Matter Too
A Roth conversion is usually framed around one comparison:
What tax rate are you paying now versus what tax rate will you pay later?
That's still important.
But if legacy is a meaningful goal, there may be a third tax rate to consider:
What tax rate could your children pay on the inherited money?
Suppose you're in a moderate tax bracket during retirement.
Your children are physicians, executives, business owners, or otherwise high earners.
Leaving them a large traditional IRA may push more income into years when they are already paying relatively high marginal rates.
In that case, deliberately paying some tax earlier through Roth conversions may deserve more consideration.
But the reverse can also be true.
If you are in a very high tax bracket today and your children are likely to be in lower brackets when they inherit, aggressively converting everything may simply accelerate tax at an unnecessarily high rate.
That's why the answer isn't:
Roth is always better for heirs.
The answer is:
Look at the family tax picture across time.
The Surviving Spouse Matters Before the Children Do
There's another reason legacy planning often starts before inheritance.
When one spouse dies, the survivor's tax situation can change materially.
The year of death can generally still qualify for married filing jointly, assuming the normal requirements are met. After that, a surviving spouse may eventually move into a different filing status depending on their circumstances.
That can create a situation where:
- Household income falls
- One Social Security benefit may disappear
- But required distributions and investment income continue
- And tax brackets become less favorable for the survivor
This concern came through clearly in the Knop conversation.
They weren't only thinking about the children's inheritance.
They were also asking:
“What happens tax-wise if one of us dies first?”
That is part of the same planning problem.
So before optimizing for the kids, we often want to model the surviving spouse first.
Roth Conversions Can Be a Legacy Tool
A Roth conversion can potentially solve several problems at once.
It may:
- Reduce future pre-tax balances
- Reduce future RMD exposure
- Move more assets into a Roth structure
- Create more tax flexibility for the surviving spouse
- Potentially leave heirs with a different tax profile
That doesn't make the strategy automatically right.
It simply means Roth conversions can be about much more than:
“Will my tax rate be higher next year?”
For someone who is highly likely to leave substantial assets behind, the time horizon may extend beyond their own life.
That's a fundamentally different planning framework.
But Don't Pay Tax Just to Say You Paid It
There is also a danger in becoming too aggressive.
Some retirees start viewing pre-tax money almost like a liability:
“We have to get rid of this IRA before the kids inherit it.”
We wouldn't think about it that way.
An inherited traditional IRA is still an inheritance.
If your child receives $500,000 and eventually pays tax on the distributions, they are still receiving a substantial asset.
One couple we spoke with actually had different emotional reactions to this issue.
One spouse felt strongly that they should take responsibility for the deferred tax rather than passing that burden to the next generation.
The other agreed that reducing the burden would be valuable, but was more comfortable with the idea that the children might still inherit some taxable money.
That's an important reminder:
Legacy planning isn't purely mathematical.
It is also about values.
Ask What You Actually Want the Inheritance to Accomplish
Before running conversion software, we would ask:
What do you actually want for your children?
Do you want to:
- Maximize the after-tax inheritance?
- Reduce future tax complexity?
- Give more during your lifetime?
- Leave Roth assets specifically?
- Fund grandchildren?
- Give to charity?
- Preserve as much as possible for yourself first?
Different answers create different tax strategies.
And sometimes the best legacy decision isn't a Roth conversion at all.
Maybe it is gifting.
Maybe it is charitable planning.
Maybe it is spending more while you're alive.
Maybe it is intentionally leaving the traditional IRA alone.
The strategy should follow the goal.
Don't Forget That You Earned the Money
This is probably the most important guardrail.
Your children can matter deeply without becoming the primary objective of your retirement plan.
One client put it well in conversation:
They wanted to minimize the tax burden their children eventually inherit, but they were still the ones who earned the money and wanted the freedom to enjoy it first.
We agree with that hierarchy.
First:
Fund your retirement.
Then:
Protect the surviving spouse.
Then:
Optimize what's likely to remain.
That's a much healthier framework than sacrificing current lifestyle purely to create the most tax-efficient inheritance possible.
A Practical Roth-Conversion Framework for Legacy Planning
If legacy is becoming a larger priority, these are the questions we'd want to answer:
- Is your own retirement sufficiently funded?
- How much pre-tax money are you likely to have later in life?
- What could future RMDs look like?
- What happens financially and tax-wise if one spouse dies first?
- What tax bracket are you in today?
- What tax brackets might you face after retirement?
- What tax situation are your children likely to be in when they inherit?
- How much cash is available to pay conversion taxes without disrupting the plan?
- How much of the estate is actually likely to reach the children?
- How important is leaving tax-efficient assets compared with spending or gifting during your lifetime?
Only after those questions are answered would we decide how aggressive the Roth-conversion strategy should be.
The Bigger Idea: Think in Family Lifetimes
Traditional tax planning often asks:
How do we minimize taxes during your life?
Legacy tax planning asks a broader question:
How do we make intelligent tax decisions across your lifetime, your spouse's lifetime, and eventually your children's?
Sometimes that means paying tax earlier.
Sometimes it means waiting.
Sometimes it means converting gradually over many years.
Sometimes it means doing very little.
The objective isn't to eliminate taxes completely.
It's to decide who should pay them, when they should pay them, and at what likely rate.
The Bottom Line
If you're likely to leave substantial retirement assets behind, Roth conversions may eventually become more than a retirement tax strategy.
They can become part of your legacy plan.
But the goal should not simply be:
“Convert everything so the kids don't pay tax.”
The better goal is:
Build a strategy that protects your retirement first, prepares for the surviving spouse, and then considers how to pass remaining wealth as intelligently as possible.
At Apeiron Planning Partners, we think legacy planning works best when estate planning, retirement income, Roth conversions, RMDs, and family goals are considered together.
Because the question isn't only:
“How much will our children inherit?”
It's:
“What will they inherit, and what will that mean for them?”
Learn more about retirement planning
Learn more about estate planning