Why Your AGI Doesn't Tell You How Much Room You Have for a Roth Conversion
You're retired.
You pull up your tax projection and see adjusted gross income of $400,000.
Then someone suggests doing another $100,000 Roth conversion while staying in the 24% tax bracket.
Your immediate reaction might be:
How is that possible?
If my income is already $400,000, haven't I basically used the entire 24% bracket?
Not necessarily.
This is one of the more confusing parts of Roth conversion planning because AGI, taxable income, ordinary income and long-term capital gains are not interchangeable numbers.
And if you treat them as though they are, you can dramatically underestimate how much Roth conversion room you actually have.
The easiest way we explain it is as a layered cake.
Ordinary income forms one layer.
Long-term capital gains and qualified dividends can sit on top under their own preferential tax-rate structure.
Understanding those layers can completely change a Roth conversion decision.
First: AGI Is Not Your Tax Bracket
Let's start with the first common mistake.
Your Adjusted Gross Income, or AGI, is not the number you simply compare against the federal income-tax brackets.
Imagine your AGI is:
$400,000
You might look at the tax brackets and conclude:
We're already around $400,000. There can't be much room left.
But there are several steps between AGI and the amount ultimately subject to the ordinary-income tax brackets.
You may have:
a standard or itemized deduction
qualified dividends
long-term capital gains
other preferentially taxed income
That means two retirees can each have $400,000 of AGI and have very different amounts of income actually being taxed through the ordinary-income brackets.
That's why we don't start Roth conversion planning by asking:
What's your AGI?
We start by asking:
What's actually inside your income?
Think of Your Tax Return Like a Layered Cake
Suppose a retired married couple has income from:
interest
pension income
Social Security
IRA distributions
a Roth conversion
qualified dividends
long-term capital gains
Those dollars do not necessarily all receive the same tax treatment.
A useful way to visualize it is:
Layer 1: Ordinary Income
This might include:
pension income
taxable IRA withdrawals
Roth conversions
interest
short-term capital gains
some dividends
taxable Social Security
That layer is generally subject to the ordinary federal income-tax brackets.
Layer 2: Preferentially Taxed Income
Then you may have:
qualified dividends
long-term capital gains
Those dollars are generally subject to the separate long-term capital-gain rate structure.
They still matter.
They're still income.
They can affect your overall taxable income and numerous other tax calculations.
But they are not simply taxed at your ordinary marginal income-tax rate because they appear inside AGI.
That distinction matters enormously when evaluating a Roth conversion.
A Simplified Example
Suppose a married couple has $400,000 of taxable income.
At first glance, that sounds like they're nearly at the top of the 24% ordinary-income bracket.
But imagine $175,000 of that taxable income consists of long-term capital gains and qualified dividends.
That leaves roughly:
$225,000 of ordinary taxable income.
For 2026, the 24% ordinary federal income-tax bracket for a married couple filing jointly extends from $211,400 through $403,550.
So although total taxable income is $400,000, this couple may still have substantial room for additional ordinary income within the 24% bracket.
That additional ordinary income could potentially come from a Roth conversion.
This is the part that surprises people:
A $400,000 income number does not necessarily mean you have $400,000 filling the ordinary-income tax brackets.
You have to understand what created the $400,000.
Why Long-Term Capital Gains Don't Simply "Fill Up" the 24% Bracket
Long-term capital gains are still part of taxable income.
They don't disappear.
But the federal tax calculation effectively separates ordinary taxable income from qualified dividends and long-term capital gains and applies the appropriate rate structure to each.
That's why simply looking at the total income number can be misleading.
Imagine:
Scenario A
$400,000 of taxable income, almost entirely pension and IRA income.
Versus:
Scenario B
$400,000 of taxable income, but $175,000 comes from long-term capital gains.
Those households can have very different Roth conversion opportunities.
The headline income number is identical.
The tax composition is not.
Why This Matters So Much for Retirees
Retirement tends to create more control over the composition of income.
While you're working, wages frequently dominate the tax return.
After retirement, income might come from:
taxable brokerage accounts
IRAs
Roth IRAs
Social Security
pensions
deferred compensation
rental properties
cash
capital gains
qualified dividends
And some of those income sources can be controlled.
You might decide how much to withdraw from an IRA.
You might decide whether to realize a capital gain.
You might decide whether to convert $50,000 or $150,000 to Roth.
You might delay Social Security.
You might bunch charitable gifts into one year.
That flexibility is one reason the years immediately after retirement can create valuable tax-planning opportunities.
We discuss the broader opportunity in Tax-Focused Retirement Planning in Dallas.
Roth Conversion Planning Is About Marginal Dollars
This is another important distinction.
Imagine your AGI is already $450,000.
That number by itself doesn't tell us what tax rate applies to the next $1 of Roth conversion.
That's what we care about.
If the next $50,000 of Roth conversion is taxed primarily at 24%, that's very different from the next $50,000 being taxed at 32%.
And that comparison becomes even more important if we believe the same IRA dollars may eventually be withdrawn at:
24%
32%
35%
or potentially higher rates for heirs
The question isn't:
What is my average tax rate this year?
It's:
What tax rate are we intentionally paying on the next dollars we convert, and what do we think the alternative is later?
That's the heart of Roth conversion planning.
Why We Don't Automatically Fill the Entire Bracket
Once someone understands this, the next reaction is often:
Great. If I have $150,000 left in the 24% bracket, let's convert all $150,000.
Not necessarily.
The ordinary-income bracket is only one variable.
A larger Roth conversion can affect other parts of the financial plan.
For example:
Medicare IRMAA
taxation of Social Security
deductions
credits
charitable strategies
ACA subsidies for younger retirees
state income taxes
capital-gain rates
Net Investment Income Tax
future-year tax planning
That's why we don't think the goal should automatically be:
Fill the bracket.
The better goal is:
Determine how much conversion creates the best long-term outcome after considering everything else it affects.
What About Medicare IRMAA?
This is a good example.
A larger Roth conversion can increase Modified Adjusted Gross Income used to determine future Medicare premiums.
So someone might say:
I don't want to cross the next IRMAA threshold, so we should stop converting.
Maybe.
But suppose crossing that threshold costs a married couple a few thousand additional dollars of Medicare premiums while allowing another $75,000 to be converted at a tax rate we believe is attractive.
Avoiding IRMAA isn't automatically the better financial decision.
We would compare the cost.
If paying an additional $3,000 of Medicare premiums allows us to execute a strategy expected to save substantially more in future taxes, the higher Medicare premium may simply be part of the cost of the plan.
We discuss that interaction more in Retiring After a High-Income Career: How to Reduce IRMAA When Medicare Is Upcoming.
A tax-efficient decision is not automatically the best financial decision.
Neither is an IRMAA-efficient decision.
Long-Term Capital Gains Still Matter
None of this means long-term capital gains can be ignored.
Far from it.
Capital gains can still:
affect the capital-gain rate applied to additional gains
increase AGI or MAGI
affect Medicare IRMAA
contribute to Net Investment Income Tax exposure
affect deductions or other income-based tax provisions
They are simply a different layer of the tax calculation.
This can create interesting planning opportunities.
Imagine you expect next year to be particularly sensitive to an income threshold.
Perhaps next year is a year when you want to maximize itemized deductions.
Perhaps you're trying to stay underneath a particular Medicare or tax threshold.
Perhaps a large deferred-compensation payment will arrive.
It may actually make sense to realize some long-term gains this year, when the tax picture is already less flexible, rather than allowing those gains to consume valuable planning flexibility next year.
That's why annual tax planning isn't just about asking:
How much tax can I save this year?
Sometimes the better question is:
Which tax year should bear which income?
Why the Standard Deduction Versus Itemizing Can Matter
Suppose you're deciding whether to pay property taxes in December or January.
If you're already taking the standard deduction this year, another deductible expense may provide little or no incremental benefit.
But if bunching that expense into next year pushes you meaningfully above the standard deduction, it could become more valuable.
Now add Roth conversions.
Perhaps next year you intentionally do a smaller Roth conversion to preserve another tax opportunity.
This is why tax planning gets complicated quickly.
The Roth conversion cannot be evaluated independently from:
deductions
gains
charitable giving
Medicare
future distributions
and the timing of other income
The tax return is one interconnected system.
Why We Like Doing Roth Conversion Planning Later in the Year
There is value in planning Roth conversions throughout the year.
But we often like sharpening the final conversion later in the year because more of the tax picture is known.
By October or November, we may have a better understanding of:
realized capital gains
dividends
pension income
consulting income
charitable giving
property taxes
portfolio distributions
Social Security
other unexpected income
Then we can update the projection and decide whether the original Roth-conversion target still makes sense.
That doesn't mean waiting until December 30.
Execution takes time.
But tax planning is usually better when we're working with more complete information instead of blindly executing a January estimate.
This is also why we believe retirees should review their tax return every year.
The previous return helps us understand what happened.
The current-year projection helps us decide what should happen next.
AGI, Taxable Income and Ordinary Income: The Simple Version
If you're trying to determine how much Roth conversion room you have, these three terms should not be treated as interchangeable.
AGI
A broad measure of income before the standard or itemized deduction.
Useful for many tax thresholds.
Not the number you simply compare against the ordinary-income tax brackets.
Taxable Income
Generally AGI after applicable deductions.
This number can contain both ordinary income and preferentially taxed income.
Ordinary Taxable Income
For purposes of thinking through the layered tax calculation, this is the portion of taxable income subject to the ordinary rate structure rather than preferential long-term capital-gain rates.
That distinction is where substantial Roth conversion opportunities can sometimes hide.
A Better Roth Conversion Planning Process
Instead of asking:
My AGI is $400,000. Can I still convert?
We would work through the problem differently.
First, estimate all expected income for the year.
Then separate:
ordinary income
qualified dividends
long-term capital gains
Next, estimate deductions.
Then determine how much ordinary taxable income is actually filling the ordinary brackets.
After that, model different Roth-conversion amounts.
Maybe:
$50,000
$100,000
$125,000
$150,000
Then look at what each conversion does to:
ordinary tax
capital-gain taxation
Medicare
Net Investment Income Tax
deductions
charitable planning
future RMDs
future tax brackets
Finally, compare this year's conversion opportunity against the opportunities we expect over the next several years.
That's a financial-planning decision.
Not simply a tax-bracket lookup.
Don't Let One Income Number Make the Decision for You
This is ultimately the mistake we're trying to avoid.
You look at a tax projection.
You see:
AGI: $425,000
and conclude:
We're already in a high bracket. No more Roth conversions.
But perhaps $175,000 of that income is long-term capital gains.
Perhaps the ordinary-income layer is dramatically lower.
Perhaps significant conversion room remains at a tax rate you're comfortable paying.
Or perhaps the opposite is true.
Maybe AGI looks relatively low, but another conversion creates expensive secondary consequences elsewhere.
You don't know until you separate the pieces.
The Bottom Line
Your AGI does not tell you how much Roth conversion room you have.
Neither does one headline number called "taxable income."
To understand the opportunity, you have to know what type of income created those numbers.
Think of the tax return like a layered cake.
Ordinary income creates one layer.
Qualified dividends and long-term capital gains can create another.
Then deductions, Medicare, future RMDs and other tax rules interact around them.
Once you see those layers, a tax return that initially looks "full" may still contain meaningful Roth conversion room.
That's why we don't ask only:
What is your income this year?
We ask:
What kind of income is it, what tax rate applies to the next dollar, and how does today's decision affect the next 10 years?
That's where Roth conversion planning actually begins.
Related Resources
Roth Conversions for Legacy Planning: Should You Pay the Tax Before Your Children Inherit?
Retiring After a High-Income Career: How to Reduce IRMAA When Medicare Is Upcoming
This material is for educational purposes only and is not intended as individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and tax law may change. Consider coordinating Roth conversion decisions with qualified financial and tax professionals.