Should You Take Your RMD in January or Wait Until the End of the Year?
Once Required Minimum Distributions begin, one thing is certain:
The IRS expects the money to come out.
What is less obvious is when you should take it.
Should you take your entire RMD in January and get it over with?
Wait until December so the money stays invested longer?
Take a little each month like a paycheck?
Or send some of it directly to charity?
All of those can make sense.
The better question isn't:
When is the best time to take an RMD?
It's:
What do you want the RMD to accomplish?
First: What Is an RMD?
Required Minimum Distributions, or RMDs, are minimum annual withdrawals generally required from tax-deferred retirement accounts once you reach the applicable RMD age.
Under current law, the applicable age is generally 73 for many current retirees and rises to 75 for individuals born in 1960 or later.
RMDs generally apply to accounts such as:
traditional IRAs
rollover IRAs
SEP and SIMPLE IRAs
401(k)s
403(b)s
certain other employer retirement plans
Roth IRAs generally do not require lifetime RMDs for the original owner under current rules.
The amount is based largely on the prior year-end account balance and an IRS life-expectancy factor.
But once you know how much must come out, you still have another decision:
When?
And if you already know you will not need the distribution for spending, that creates a separate planning question entirely. We walk through several options in What to Do With Excess RMDs.
Option 1: Take the RMD Early in the Year
Some retirees prefer taking their entire RMD in January.
There is a lot to like about the simplicity.
You satisfy the requirement.
You don't have to remember it in November or December.
And the cash can immediately be moved wherever it needs to go.
Pros of Taking the RMD Early
You eliminate the risk of forgetting it.
RMD mistakes can create penalties and unnecessary administrative work.
Taking it early removes the issue for the rest of the year.
You can fund spending immediately.
If you're going to use the distribution for living expenses anyway, there may be little reason to leave those dollars inside the IRA.
Taxes can be handled immediately.
You can withhold federal taxes directly from the distribution instead of making separate estimated payments.
Cons of Taking the RMD Early
You lose tax-deferred growth on those dollars earlier.
Once the money leaves the IRA, future earnings may occur in a taxable account.
You have less flexibility later in the year.
Maybe you planned to give money to charity.
Maybe your income changes.
Maybe you realize later that a Qualified Charitable Distribution would have been useful.
Once the RMD has already been distributed to you, you can't retroactively turn that same distribution into a QCD.
That's why "get it over with" isn't always the best planning strategy.
Option 2: Wait Until the End of the Year
Other retirees do the opposite.
They leave the money inside the retirement account as long as possible and take the RMD later in the year.
Pros of Waiting
The money remains tax-deferred longer.
If the assets grow during the year, those dollars remain inside the retirement account.
You have more information.
By November or December you may have a much clearer picture of:
taxable income
realized capital gains
charitable giving
withholding
Roth conversions
Medicare-related income
year-end spending
That information can help coordinate the distribution with the rest of the tax plan.
This is one reason we like to view the tax return as a planning document, not just a filing obligation. We explain that process in Why Retirees Should Review Their Tax Return Every Year.
Cons of Waiting
The obvious problem:
You can forget.
December gets busy.
Custodians have processing deadlines.
Holidays happen.
Transfers get delayed.
Waiting until December 30 to think about the RMD is not a strategy.
It's a deadline.
Option 3: Take the RMD Throughout the Year
For retirees who actually use their IRA to fund their lifestyle, monthly or quarterly distributions can be very practical.
Instead of taking a $48,000 RMD at once, someone might distribute $4,000 per month.
Now the RMD functions like a paycheck.
Advantages
predictable cash flow
systematic tax withholding
less need to keep a large checking balance
reduced risk of forgetting the annual requirement
Disadvantages
You have to track the distributions.
And if other planning opportunities arise later in the year, some of the RMD has already been taken.
Again, there is no universal winner.
The strategy should match the retiree.
What If You Don't Need the Money?
This is where RMD planning gets more interesting.
A lot of retirees eventually reach the point where:
The IRS says they have to take money out, but they don't actually need it to live.
That creates a different planning question: what should you actually do with the distribution?
We cover the broader decision in What to Do With Excess RMDs, but several common options include the following.
Reinvest It in a Brokerage Account
An RMD does not mean the money has to be spent.
You can take the distribution, pay whatever tax is due, and reinvest the remaining proceeds in a taxable brokerage account.
The money simply moves from a tax-deferred account to an accessible investment account.
That can make sense when the goal is continued long-term growth.
Add It to Cash Reserves
Sometimes the portfolio needs less complexity, not more.
If upcoming expenses include:
a new vehicle
travel
home improvements
family gifts
property taxes
the RMD may simply refill cash reserves.
Use It for Gifting
Some retirees use excess RMD proceeds for gifts to children or grandchildren.
That doesn't make the RMD itself tax-free, but it can be a useful way to coordinate required distributions with legacy goals.
Use a Qualified Charitable Distribution
For charitably inclined retirees, this is one of the more valuable planning opportunities.
A Qualified Charitable Distribution allows an eligible IRA owner age 70½ or older to transfer money directly from an IRA to an eligible charity.
A qualifying QCD can count toward an RMD while generally keeping that distribution out of adjusted gross income, subject to the applicable annual rules and limits.
That can be particularly useful because adjusted gross income can affect more than the income-tax bill.
It can also affect things such as Medicare premiums.
QCDs are also just one piece of a broader charitable strategy. If giving is already part of your financial plan, we discuss several other approaches in Charitable Giving Strategies in Retirement.
Why QCD Timing Matters
Here's an easy mistake.
Suppose your RMD is $40,000.
In January, you withdraw the entire $40,000 to your bank account.
Then in October you decide you want to donate $20,000 to charity.
You may still make the charitable gift.
But the January RMD has already been distributed to you.
You can't go back and transform it into a QCD.
That's why charitably inclined retirees may want to coordinate QCDs before automatically taking the entire RMD.
The order of operations matters.
And that is a good example of why annual tax planning should not stop once a tax return is filed. Looking back at the completed return can show whether QCDs, withholding, capital gains and other strategies actually showed up the way you expected. We discuss that in Why Retirees Should Review Their Tax Return Every Year.
Should You Delay Your First RMD Until the Following Year?
There is a special rule for the first RMD.
Depending on the situation, an individual can generally delay the first RMD until April 1 of the following year.
That sounds attractive.
More tax deferral.
But there is a catch.
The second RMD is still generally due by December 31 of that same year.
So delaying the first distribution can create two taxable RMDs in one calendar year.
That could potentially:
increase taxable income
push income into a higher marginal tax bracket
affect taxation of other income
increase Medicare IRMAA exposure
reduce other tax-planning flexibility
Sometimes delaying is still beneficial.
But "the IRS lets me wait" doesn't mean waiting is automatically the better financial decision.
The tax answer should not live in a vacuum.
Can You Combine RMDs From Different Accounts?
Sometimes.
And sometimes not.
This is an area where mistakes happen.
For example, traditional IRA RMD amounts can generally be calculated separately and then satisfied by taking the combined required amount from one or more eligible IRAs.
But you generally cannot simply combine an IRA RMD with a 401(k) RMD and take everything from the IRA.
Employer retirement plans often need to satisfy their own RMD requirements separately.
And married couples can't take one spouse's RMD on behalf of the other.
Your accounts may be jointly part of the household financial plan.
The RMD obligation is still individual.
What About the Still-Working Exception?
Another common source of confusion.
Someone can be over RMD age and still working.
Does that mean they can delay all RMDs?
Not necessarily.
Under current rules, qualifying participants in a current employer's workplace retirement plan may be able to delay RMDs from that plan until retirement, generally subject to plan rules and the 5% owner restriction.
But that doesn't automatically delay RMDs from traditional IRAs or old employer retirement accounts.
This is exactly why RMD planning can become more complicated when someone has accumulated several retirement accounts over a long career.
The RMD Is Also a Tax-Withholding Tool
One underappreciated feature of retirement distributions is withholding.
Someone who realizes late in the year that they have underpaid taxes may be able to use withholding from an IRA distribution as part of the solution.
That can make the timing of a late-year RMD valuable beyond simply satisfying the distribution requirement.
This is another reason we don't like treating the RMD as an isolated administrative event.
It is part of the annual tax plan.
And once the year is over, reviewing the finished return can help identify whether the withholding strategy, QCDs and distributions actually worked together the way you intended. That is one of the reasons we believe retirees should review their tax return every year.
A Better RMD Planning Process
Instead of automatically taking the RMD on January 2 every year, we would think through the year in this order:
Do you need the RMD for spending?
If yes, build it into the retirement-income strategy.
If you don't need the money, what role should it play next?
It might be reinvested, added to cash reserves, gifted or coordinated with other planning goals. What to Do With Excess RMDs goes deeper into those choices.
Are you charitably inclined?
Consider QCDs before distributing all of the RMD to yourself. For retirees with broader charitable goals, Charitable Giving Strategies in Retirement provides additional approaches to consider.
Do you need additional tax withholding?
The distribution may help solve that problem.
Will you be doing Roth conversions?
Coordinate the RMD and conversion because the RMD itself generally can't be converted to Roth.
Are you close to an important Medicare or tax threshold?
Understand the total income picture first.
Do you have multiple retirement accounts?
Make sure the RMD is being taken from the correct account or accounts.
Then execute.
And after the year is complete, verify that the strategy actually showed up correctly on the return. Reviewing the tax return annually can uncover mistakes, inefficiencies and planning opportunities for the following year.
The Bottom Line
There is no universally best month to take an RMD.
January can be simple.
December can create more flexibility.
Monthly distributions can make retirement cash flow easier.
QCDs can turn an unwanted taxable distribution into part of a charitable strategy.
And excess distributions can potentially be reinvested or redirected toward other financial goals.
The important part is not trying to optimize one RMD in isolation.
It's coordinating the distribution with:
spending
taxes
charitable giving
Medicare
investments
withholding
and the rest of the retirement plan.
Because an RMD may be required.
How you use it is still a planning decision.
Related Resources
This material is for educational purposes only and is not intended as individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Tax rules and limits may change, and individual circumstances vary.