How to Manage Income for ACA Subsidies Before Medicare
Retiring before age 65 creates a healthcare problem that traditional retirement planning doesn't always prepare people for.
You may be financially independent.
You may have enough investments to stop working.
You may have plenty of money in IRAs, brokerage accounts, and cash.
But you're not yet eligible for Medicare.
So now you need health insurance.
For many early retirees, that means buying coverage through the Health Insurance Marketplace and potentially qualifying for the Premium Tax Credit, which can reduce the cost of coverage.
And that's where retirement income planning suddenly becomes healthcare planning.
Because the amount you pay for Marketplace insurance can depend heavily on how much income shows up on your tax return.
In 2026, this becomes especially important.
The temporary expansion of the Premium Tax Credit that applied through 2025 has ended. In general, households with income above 400% of the applicable federal poverty level are no longer eligible for the credit.
And beginning in 2026, if you receive more advance Premium Tax Credit than you're ultimately entitled to, the prior repayment caps are gone.
That means managing income isn't just about reducing taxes.
It can directly affect what you pay for health insurance.
The Planning Problem: You May Have Plenty of Money but Very Little "Income"
This is one of the strange things about early retirement.
Imagine someone retires at 60 with:
substantial retirement accounts,
a taxable brokerage account,
cash,
rental property,
and perhaps some part-time income.
Their net worth might be several million dollars.
But the Marketplace isn't primarily looking at net worth.
It's looking at household income.
That creates an opportunity.
If we can be thoughtful about where spending money comes from, we may be able to keep taxable income at a level that preserves some or all of the Premium Tax Credit.
But that does not mean the goal should be:
“Keep income as low as humanly possible.”
That can create bad financial decisions somewhere else.
The better question is:
“How much income should we intentionally create this year after considering taxes, healthcare subsidies, and the long-term retirement plan?”
What Income Counts for ACA Subsidies?
For Premium Tax Credit purposes, household income generally starts with adjusted gross income and then adds back certain items.
That can include:
wages,
taxable IRA withdrawals,
Roth conversions,
capital gains,
interest,
dividends,
rental income,
business income,
taxable pension income,
and other items included in adjusted gross income.
Marketplace modified adjusted gross income also generally adds back:
tax-exempt interest,
nontaxable Social Security benefits,
and certain excluded foreign income.
That last point surprises people.
You may think:
“My Social Security isn't taxable, so it shouldn't matter.”
For Marketplace subsidy purposes, nontaxable Social Security can still matter.
That's why we have to calculate the ACA income number separately rather than simply looking at taxable income.
A Small Change Can Have a Big Impact
We recently worked through a situation where a semi-retired household was trying to understand why their Marketplace subsidy changed.
The answer wasn't one giant financial event.
It was a collection of smaller moving pieces.
Part-time wages mattered.
Rental income mattered.
The deductions associated with the rental property changed.
Investment income mattered.
IRA contributions potentially mattered.
And suddenly a household that appeared to have fairly modest retirement income was much closer to an important ACA threshold than expected.
That's one of the reasons this planning can feel confusing.
Someone may say:
“I only earned $25,000 from work this year.”
But wages aren't the entire calculation.
If rental deductions decline, taxable rental income can rise.
If a mutual fund distributes capital gains, income can rise.
If you sell appreciated investments, income can rise.
If you complete a Roth conversion, income can rise.
Each decision may look small by itself.
Together, they can materially change the cost of health insurance.
In 2026, the 400% Threshold Matters Again
For tax years 2021 through 2025, the normal 400%-of-poverty upper income limit for the Premium Tax Credit was temporarily removed.
That expansion ended after 2025.
For 2026, households generally need income between 100% and 400% of the applicable federal poverty level to qualify for the Premium Tax Credit.
That makes the upper threshold especially important for early retirees.
If you're well below it, small income changes may simply reduce the size of the subsidy.
If you're close to it, an additional Roth conversion, capital gain, IRA withdrawal, or other income item can have a much larger effect.
This is where we want to know the approximate threshold before December 31.
Not when the tax return gets prepared the following spring.
Don't Confuse Tax With Withholding
This is another common source of confusion.
Suppose someone picks up part-time work.
They see federal tax being withheld from every paycheck.
They may understandably think:
“I'm already paying taxes on this income, so this shouldn't hurt me later.”
But withholding doesn't reduce the income used to calculate the Premium Tax Credit.
Withholding is simply a prepayment of the eventual tax bill.
If your wages increase household income, they can still reduce your Premium Tax Credit even though taxes were withheld from your paycheck.
Those are two separate calculations.
Roth Conversions Can Compete With ACA Subsidies
This is one of the biggest planning tradeoffs for early retirees.
The years immediately after retirement can be fantastic years for Roth conversions.
Salary may disappear.
Required Minimum Distributions haven't started.
Social Security may not have started.
Taxable income can be unusually low.
Normally, we might look at that and say:
“This is a great opportunity to intentionally move money from the traditional IRA into the Roth.”
But if you're also receiving Marketplace subsidies, the calculation changes.
Every additional dollar converted to Roth generally increases income for ACA purposes.
So you may be choosing between two valuable benefits:
Paying tax at an attractive rate today through a Roth conversion
versus
preserving a larger health-insurance subsidy.
There isn't a universal winner.
You have to calculate both.
A $20,000 Roth conversion might produce a very attractive long-term tax result.
But if it also causes you to lose thousands of dollars of health-insurance assistance, the true cost of that conversion is higher than the income-tax bill alone.
That doesn't mean:
“Never do Roth conversions before Medicare.”
It means:
The healthcare cost should be included when we calculate the conversion.
Your Brokerage Account Can Be Extremely Valuable Before Medicare
This is another reason we like taxable brokerage accounts for people who want to retire early.
Suppose you need $80,000 to live on.
If you withdraw $80,000 from a traditional IRA, most or all of that distribution may increase your income.
But suppose you sell $80,000 from a brokerage account.
Maybe $60,000 represents your original cost basis and only $20,000 represents a capital gain.
The amount of cash available for spending and the amount added to income can be dramatically different.
That's an important distinction.
A taxable brokerage account can potentially allow an early retiree to fund a substantial amount of spending without creating the same amount of ACA income.
This doesn't make brokerage accounts magically tax-free.
Capital gains, dividends, and interest still matter.
But they can give us more control.
And before Medicare, control over taxable income can be extremely valuable.
High-Basis Investments Can Be Especially Useful
Let's take that one step further.
Suppose an early retiree owns two investments.
Investment A is worth $100,000 with an $85,000 cost basis.
Investment B is worth $100,000 with a $30,000 cost basis.
Selling Investment A creates approximately $15,000 of gain.
Selling Investment B creates approximately $70,000.
Both produce $100,000 of cash.
But they can have very different effects on Marketplace income.
That means which investments you sell can matter just as much as how much you spend.
This is why withdrawal planning becomes so important between retirement and Medicare.
Tax-Loss Harvesting Can Help Manage the Number
Investment losses can sometimes create another lever.
If you realize capital gains during the year, realized losses may offset some of those gains.
That can help reduce adjusted gross income.
For someone close to an ACA subsidy threshold, that can become particularly valuable.
Again, we aren't creating investment losses simply to receive cheaper health insurance.
The investment decision has to make sense first.
But if there is an appropriate opportunity to tax-loss harvest, the impact on Marketplace income should be considered.
Traditional IRA Contributions May Help in Some Situations
Semi-retirement creates another interesting planning opportunity.
Suppose someone leaves their primary career but continues working part time.
If they have earned income and otherwise qualify to make a deductible traditional IRA contribution, the deduction may reduce adjusted gross income.
That can potentially help with both:
federal income taxes, and
Marketplace subsidy calculations.
In one planning situation we evaluated, this was particularly useful because the client still had part-time wages.
Rather than only looking at:
“How much did you earn?”
we could ask:
“Are there legitimate deductions available that reduce the income that ultimately matters?”
Whether an IRA contribution is deductible depends on the person's specific circumstances, so this needs to be evaluated individually.
Rental Property Can Make ACA Planning Messier
Rental real estate is another area where the Marketplace calculation can become less predictable.
The important number isn't necessarily the rent deposited into your bank account.
It's the taxable result after the applicable rental income and expenses are calculated.
That means changes in:
repairs,
depreciation,
property expenses,
vacancy,
interest,
or other deductible items
can change the amount appearing on the tax return.
In one situation we reviewed, rental deductions had declined substantially from the prior year.
The result was effectively more taxable rental income than the household expected.
Nothing dramatic happened.
But their ACA income number moved.
That's why relying solely on last year's income can be dangerous.
Selling a Rental Property Can Blow Up the Subsidy for One Year
This becomes even more important when an early retiree is considering selling appreciated property.
A rental sale may create:
capital gains,
depreciation recapture,
and potentially other taxable income.
That can make preserving an ACA subsidy difficult or impossible for that year.
And that's okay.
This is where we don't want the healthcare subsidy tail wagging the financial-planning dog.
Suppose selling the property is clearly the right long-term decision.
Maybe:
the client doesn't want to be a landlord anymore,
the property is becoming difficult to manage,
the proceeds can be diversified,
or selling substantially improves the retirement plan.
It may make no sense to keep an unwanted property for another year solely to preserve several thousand dollars of Premium Tax Credit.
The subsidy matters.
But it is one variable.
The broader financial decision still comes first.
Sometimes You Intentionally Sacrifice the Subsidy
This is an important point.
The goal isn't to maximize ACA subsidies every year.
The goal is to maximize the overall financial plan.
Maybe this is the perfect year to:
sell a property,
realize a large gain,
convert a meaningful amount to Roth,
exercise equity compensation,
or make another financially valuable move.
If that pushes income above the subsidy threshold, so be it.
We should understand the consequence before making the decision.
But we shouldn't automatically avoid a good long-term move because it increases this year's health-insurance premium.
We think about it similarly to taxes:
A tax-efficient decision is not automatically the best financial decision.
The same is true with healthcare subsidies.
2026 Makes Income Estimates More Important
Marketplace subsidies can be paid in advance during the year.
The Marketplace estimates how much Premium Tax Credit you should receive based on the income information you provide.
Then when you file your tax return, you reconcile the advance credit with the amount you were actually entitled to receive.
Beginning in 2026, this deserves extra attention.
If you received more advance Premium Tax Credit than you ultimately qualify for, the prior repayment limitations no longer apply.
You may have to repay the full excess amount.
So if income increases materially during the year, don't simply wait until tax season.
Consider updating the Marketplace.
For example, maybe you:
return to work,
complete a large Roth conversion,
sell a property,
realize a significant gain,
receive a large retirement distribution,
or experience another major income change.
Updating the estimate can reduce the chance of an unpleasant surprise later.
Build a Buffer If You're Near the Threshold
If someone's projected income is extremely close to the upper ACA threshold, we generally don't want to plan to the exact dollar.
Why?
Because not every income item is perfectly predictable.
A mutual fund might distribute a capital gain.
Interest income might be higher than expected.
A rental-property result may change.
An unexpected bonus could arrive.
The year-end investment picture may move.
So rather than aiming for:
“We can earn exactly $1 less than the threshold,”
we'd usually prefer some margin for error.
Especially in 2026, when exceeding the applicable income limit can result in losing eligibility for the credit and excess advance credits may need to be repaid in full.
Think in Terms of an Income Budget
One way we like to make this less abstract is to treat Marketplace income almost like a budget.
Suppose we've estimated that there is a particular income range we want to stay within.
We can start with the income we already expect:
Part-time wages
plus
rental income
plus
interest and dividends
plus
Social Security included for ACA purposes
plus
realized capital gains
plus
IRA distributions
Then we ask:
How much room is left?
Maybe there is room for a Roth conversion.
Maybe there isn't.
Maybe we should harvest losses.
Maybe we should fund spending from high-basis brokerage assets.
Maybe a deductible IRA contribution makes sense.
Instead of ACA planning feeling like some vague tax rule, we now have a number we're intentionally managing.
The Retirement-to-Medicare Window Is a Unique Planning Period
For many people, the years between retirement and age 65 are unlike any other period in their financial lives.
Salary may be gone.
Social Security may not have started.
RMDs may still be years away.
You may be living mostly from investments.
And health insurance may depend on the income you intentionally create.
That's a lot of flexibility.
But flexibility only helps if it's coordinated.
The same dollar can affect:
federal income taxes,
capital gains,
Roth-conversion strategy,
Marketplace subsidies,
and eventually the amount of money available later in retirement.
That's why we don't want the investment plan, tax plan, and healthcare plan operating independently.
A Practical ACA Income-Planning Checklist
If you're retiring before Medicare and using Marketplace coverage, these are some of the questions we'd want to answer:
What is our expected household income for ACA purposes?
What is the applicable Premium Tax Credit income range for our household?
How close are we to the upper threshold?
Are either spouse's wages still creating income?
Have we included nontaxable Social Security when calculating ACA MAGI?
What IRA distributions do we expect?
Are we considering Roth conversions?
What capital gains might our brokerage portfolio create?
Are there losses available to offset gains?
Is rental income likely to change?
Are we considering selling real estate?
Could a deductible IRA contribution reduce AGI?
Which brokerage assets have the highest cost basis?
How much spending can come from cash without creating income?
Have we left a buffer for unexpected income?
If income materially changes, should we update the Marketplace estimate?
The goal is not to keep income artificially low forever.
It's to make conscious decisions about when income appears.
The Bottom Line
Retiring before Medicare creates an unusual financial-planning opportunity.
You may have significant wealth while still having substantial control over how much income appears on your tax return.
That can affect what you pay for Marketplace health insurance.
But the goal should not simply be:
“Get the biggest ACA subsidy possible.”
Sometimes preserving the subsidy makes sense.
Sometimes a Roth conversion is more valuable.
Sometimes selling the rental property is more important.
Sometimes realizing gains is the right decision.
And sometimes using a high-basis brokerage account gives you the best of both worlds.
The real planning question is:
“How should we create the income we need while balancing taxes, healthcare costs, and the rest of the retirement plan?”
At Apeiron Planning Partners, that's how we think about the years between retirement and Medicare.
Not as a standalone healthcare decision.
But as a tax, investment, and retirement-income decision that all needs to work together.
Learn more about retirement planning
Why High Earners Need Brokerage Accounts Beyond Their 401(k)
How Much Money Do You Need Outside Your 401(k) to Retire Early?
Related Resources
Why High Earners Need Brokerage Accounts Beyond Their 401(k)
How Much Money Do You Need Outside Your 401(k) to Retire Early?
This material is for general informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as individualized financial, investment, tax, legal, or healthcare advice. Affordable Care Act rules, Premium Tax Credit eligibility, federal poverty guidelines, Marketplace premiums, tax laws, and retirement-plan rules may change over time. Individual circumstances vary. Readers should confirm current rules with the Health Insurance Marketplace, IRS, and their appropriate financial, tax, legal, and healthcare professionals before implementing a strategy.